Linear Social MDP

Scenarios

We apply the Linear Social MDP in a 10x10 grid-world environment, for 2 robots with five actions (move in one of four directions or stay in place), three physical goals (watering the tree, adding logs to a fire and sawing logs), three locations (tree, fire, and saw), and two objects (a log, and a water can). In addition to the three physical goals, any combination of physical goals is possible, along with one of five social goals (cooperation, conflict, competition, coercion, or exchange) each related to one or more physical goals. Robots can move objects by pushing them. In all the experiments each robot always attempts to achieve two physical goals while engaging in social interactions relative to those goals. Those social interactions are conditioned on the physical goals of the other agent; or rather, on what the first agent thinks the second agent is doing. Despite having a fully-observable environment, agents do not have access to each others internal states and must estimate each others goals. We explored every social scenario in this environment. The Yellow robot always had at most one social interaction, while the Red robot always had at most two social interactions. This resulted in 6x6x5 = 180 scenarios (eliminating the cause where neither agent considers any social interaction).

Scenario # Yellow Robot Red Robot
Social Goal 1 Social Goal 2 Physical Goal 1 Physical Goal 2 Social Goal 1 Social Goal 2 Physical Goal 1 Physical Goal 2
Scenario 1 Cooperate on Fire None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw Cooperate on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 2 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 3 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 4 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 5 Cooperate on Fire None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 6 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 7 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Cooperate on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 8 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 9 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 10 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Coercion on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 11 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Exchange on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 12 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 13 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Cooperate on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 14 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 15 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 16 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 17 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 18 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 19 Cooperate on Tree None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Cooperate on Saw Tree Tree
Scenario 20 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 21 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 22 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 23 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 24 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 25 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 26 Cooperate on Tree None Saw Tree Exchange on Saw Conflict on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 27 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 28 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 29 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 30 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 31 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 32 Cooperate on Fire None Saw Tree Neutral on Saw Conflict on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 33 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 34 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 35 Cooperate on Fire None Saw Tree Neutral on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 36 Cooperate on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 37 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw Cooperate on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 38 Conflict on Fire None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw Conflict on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 39 Conflict on Fire None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw Compete on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 40 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 41 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 42 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Cooperate on Saw None on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 43 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Cooperate on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 44 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Conflict on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 45 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Compete on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 46 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Coercion on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 47 Conflict on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 48 Conflict on Tree None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw None on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 49 Conflict on Fire None Saw Tree Compete on Saw Cooperate on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 50 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 51 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 52 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 53 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 54 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree None on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 55 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 56 Conflict on Fire None Saw Tree Coercion on Saw Conflict on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 57 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 58 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 59 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Exchange on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 60 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 61 Conflict on Fire None Tree Fire Exchange on Tree Cooperate on Fire Fire Tree
Scenario 62 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 63 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 64 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Coercion on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 65 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 66 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 67 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 68 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 69 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 70 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 71 Conflict on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 72 Conflict on Tree None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree None on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 73 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Cooperate on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 74 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 75 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 76 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 77 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Exchange on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 78 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 79 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Cooperate on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 80 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 81 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 82 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Coercion on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 83 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 84 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw None on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 85 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 86 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 87 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 88 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 89 Compete on Fire None Tree Tree Compete on Tree Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 90 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree None on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 91 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Coercion on Saw Cooperate on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 92 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 93 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 94 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 95 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 96 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 97 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 98 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 99 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 100 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 101 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Exchange on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 102 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 103 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 104 Compete on Fire None Saw Tree Neutral on Saw Conflict on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 105 Compete on Tree None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 106 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 107 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 108 Compete on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 109 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 110 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 111 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 112 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 113 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 114 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 115 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 116 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Conflict on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 117 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Compete on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 118 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Coercion on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 119 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Exchange on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 120 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw None on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 121 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 122 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 123 Coercion on Fire None Saw Tree Compete on Saw Compete on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 124 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 125 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 126 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 127 Coercion on Fire None Fire Tree Coercion on Fire Cooperate on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 128 Coercion on Tree None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Conflict on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 129 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 130 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 131 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 132 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 133 Coercion on Tree None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Cooperate on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 134 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 135 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 136 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 137 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 138 Coercion on Tree None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree None on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 139 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 140 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 141 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 142 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 143 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 144 Coercion on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 145 Exchange on Tree None Tree Fire Cooperate on Tree Cooperate on Fire Tree Fire
Scenario 146 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 147 Exchange on Tree None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 148 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 149 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 150 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Cooperate on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 151 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 152 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 153 Exchange on Fire None Saw Tree Conflict on Saw Compete on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 154 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 155 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 156 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Conflict on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 157 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 158 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 159 Exchange on Tree None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Compete on Saw Tree Fire
Scenario 160 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 161 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 162 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Compete on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 163 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 164 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 165 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 166 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 167 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 168 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Coercion on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 169 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Cooperate on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 170 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 171 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Compete on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 172 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 173 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 174 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Exchange on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 175 Exchange on Tree None Saw Tree Neutral on Saw Cooperate on Tree Tree Fire
Scenario 176 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Conflict on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 177 Exchange on Fire None Saw Tree Neutral on Saw Compete on Tree Fire Tree
Scenario 178 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Coercion on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 179 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree Exchange on Saw Fire Tree
Scenario 180 Exchange on Fire None Tree Saw Neutral on Tree None on Saw Fire Tree